Difference 2 tier vs 3 tier Architecture

Difference 2 tier vs 3 tier Architecture


2 tier vs 3 tier: Note: Before knowing the differences, it is advised to go through Introduction to 2-tier and 3-tier Architecture.
Table on 2 tier vs 3 tier
Feature 2-Tier 3-Tier
Administration Complex as business logic and database exist on one system Simple as layers are separated
Security Less secured as client can talk to database directly Highly secured as client is not allowed to talk to database directly
Scalability Poor Excellent as requests can be load balanced between servers
Services Not required as business logic application and database are tight-coupled. Application server may use services like RMI or JMS etc.
Performance Poor as second-tier should execute both business logic and database queries Good as processing is distributed between 2nd and 3rd tiers.
Deployment costs High as no granularity exists Less and ease due to builder tools
Infrastructure No extra infrastructure is required due to tight-coupling Infrastructure of middleware services can be used
Reusability Mostly clients are monolothic and thereby reusability not possible Reusability more with services implementation
Legacy integration No Yes, possible through gateways and business objects
Hardware flexibility Very limited as only one client and one server exist Best with component-based environments to distribute services between 2nd and 3rd tiers
Heterogeneous database support Only database should be used Multiple databases can be used even within the same transaction
Support for Internet Poor as bandwidth limitations may take more time for download fat client programs Best to download client programs as services supporting downloading are distributed
Availability Can use backup servers If one server fails, the services can be executed on other services
Communication choices Only connection-oriented and synchronous methods calls are permitted Can support connectionless messaging, publish-subscribe and broadcast messaging etc.

2 tier vs 3 tier: Points to note prone to different opinions:

  • There is no clear cut demarcation in security. Many people favour 3-tier for security. Sometimes, even when a 3-tier approach is not taken good care, it ends in less secured.
  • As 2-tier applications are easier to develop with less complexity, overall they are less expensive.
  • Keeping the client program compatible with the server program, in long run, is difficult which can be overcome in 3-tier. In 3-tier also, sometimes the security patches installed on server may trouble the client.

One thought on “Difference 2 tier vs 3 tier Architecture

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *